[editor’s View] To Our Readers, the Final Judges of a Scattershot Contest
32
GG Vol.
26. 10. 10.
GG is a publication that began, from its very first year, with an annual game criticism contest as part of its basic design. So rather than counting up how many years GG has run, I recall this magazine’s history by which edition of the contest a given year brought. If the GameGeneration Game Criticism Contest, now in its fifth year, is regarded as the history of GG itself, it is because this is how I think of it.
In Korea, I began to write — and then stopped, struck by the thought that events which regularly solicit game criticism are in fact rare even outside the Korean-speaking world. This year’s contest actually drew an entry from Japan that went on to win. Events that gather and award writing of this kind, in this way, must be rarer than one might think.
There will be many reasons, but the one I take to weigh most is that the concept of “game criticism” itself is used extremely broadly — and that within that breadth, the game criticism that I, and further GG, have in mind occupies a rather small territory.
There is nothing wrong with bundling the many kinds of writing and talk about games under the name of criticism. It would be more accurate to say that, among criticism’s many orientations, the criticism GG pursues is carving out another track of its own. Meaning is never fixed; it keeps changing between people’s words and writings. Criticism, too, changes not as some fixed form or value, but through the struggle over meaning that those who actually mean to practice criticism wage, each within their own field of force. Whether this orientation is right or wrong is not the question at hand. Each of us simply carries out our own criticism — and in that process, which criticism is received more widely, and more meaningfully, by society will change every time.
This is why I remain reserved about attempts to define what criticism is. I do not care for declarations of the kind “this is what it is,” or what it must be. There was an age when declarative writing carried force; but now that technology has reshaped the power relations of writing and speaking into something unlike the past, I am not sure a declaration means as much as it once did. This is a time that calls for practice rather than declaration — and I believe that GG, the contest, and the many writers who entered it stand on the front line of the practical struggle over meaning being waged around the word criticism.
Three works were selected in this year’s contest. A piece from beyond the boundary of Korea won; a discovery made in StarCraft, a classic game nearing thirty years old, won. That an essay on a game released in August 2026 also won means — to put it kindly — that this contest spans a wide stretch of time and space; to put it unkindly, that it is scattershot.
Frankly, I am quite fond of this scattershot quality. The order and the thread of it, I suspect, are better sorted out by the decoding of those who read. And so this criticism contest will be completed precisely through your reading of its final winners. The readers of GG, who take in the many voices of criticism and commune with their meanings, are the contest’s final judges. I ask for your warm attention to this issue as well.
Thank you.
Lee Kyung-hyuk, Editor-in-Chief, GameGeneration

